April 12, 2004
Yasukuni Shrine
Admittedly the act of swearing on a bible is somewhat different to praying at a shrine to dead war heros but the issue at stake was the unconstitutional nature of the Prime Minister being invovled in religion.
It is in this regard that shrine priests are inclined to disagree with the ruling or, if the constitution is so worded as to rule out acts of this kind, to want to throw out the constitution as some poisonous duff foisted upon Japan after a recent war defeat. Poisonous because, if you outlaw a nations' religion, or make it so tabuu that those in public office are not allowed to take part in any way, then that will help to destroy the influence that the religion has upon the populace, possibly to negative effect.
I think that my Shrine priest aquaintances have a point.
First of all the line between tradition and religion is very hazy. Is celebrating the new year, or Christmas religious? Is taking part in cherry blossom watching or watching Sumo religious? Is getting married religious? Is upholding morality religious? Or even is being sane religious?! I think that my belief in the existance of my identity is predicated on my belief in the existance of god. In the extreme, then, one might claim that anyone that behaves as if they have an ongoing identity is behaving in a religious way.
I think that in a lot of countries there is a a hazy line between what is acceptable for a politician to do and what is not. If the UK prime minister Blair started preaching on the merits of a particular Christian denomination then he would soon be out on his ear. But if he observes Christmas celebrations or Easter celebrations then people do not complain.
Personally I think that the Japanese should dump their constitution and allow Japanese politicians to be a little more invovled in "religion."
However I do have misgivings towards Yasukuni. It strikes me that Yasukuni is a new religion that was very much a part of Japanese aspirations to bring Asia under one Japanese roof. At the very least, since it is rather like a German prime minister saluting before a swastika - Yasukuni Shrine was a central image of the pre 1945 regime - it is clear that Asian neighbours are not going to be happy about the Prime Minister's visits. I would prefer it if the Prime Minister remembered the war dead by worshipping a mountain cherry tree*.
Boom.
You can send a letter of support or complaint to Prime Minister Koizumi here.